@Michael Pope I just looked at my criteria, because of your question, and saw I had two separate criteria for Payment Method. We have 3 custom payment methods that I wanted to exclude. I excluded 2 in the first criteria and all three in the second. Somehow this was causing the issue. When I fixed the criteria, the results populated in the export. When I added the second criteria back into the search, it exported blank again. I truly have no idea why the results would show no matter the criteria, but once exported, it would be blank.