Hello @erictgrubaugh @KevinJ of Kansas @creece Thought I give you an update. After crying myself to sleep on Friday, I decided to give myself the weekend and not touch this. Today, I simply added

.phone

and

.email

and wouldn't you know it, it worked. I have not reset cache, no updates (that I know of) have been made to our account. I have no idea why this issue was there on Friday and like magic, its gone now. Maybe it needed time to establish the table connection (I'm just reaching at this point) I'm thankful that it works now but its driving me insane not to know what the problem was.